{"sha": "3f7bd72a0486fba3f756bbb61fabda2acf6c259f", "data": {"nexml": {"@about": "#study", "@generator": "Open Tree API", "@id": "study", "@nexml2json": "1.2.1", "@nexmljson": "http://purl.org/opentree/nexson", "@version": "0.9", "@xmlns": {"$": "http://www.nexml.org/2009", "nex": "http://www.nexml.org/2009", "ot": "http://purl.org/opentree-terms#", "xhtml": "http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml/vocab#", "xsd": "http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#", "xsi": "http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"}, "^ot:agents": {"agent": [{"@description": "Open Tree NexSON validation", "@id": "peyotl-validator", "@name": "api.opentreeoflife.org/validate", "@url": "https://github.com/OpenTreeOfLife/peyotl", "@version": "0.0.4a", "invocation": {"commandLine": [], "otherProperty": [{"name": "pythonVersion", "value": "2.7.9"}, {"name": "pythonImplementation", "value": "CPython"}]}}, {"@description": "Web-based interface for submitting, editing, and reviewing studies in the Open Tree of Life project.", "@id": "opentree-curation-webapp", "@name": "OpenTree curation webapp", "@url": "https://github.com/OpenTreeOfLife/opentree", "@version": "0.0.0"}]}, "^ot:annotationEvents": {"annotation": [{"@dateCreated": "2016-09-29T18:56:21.387Z", "@description": "Aids for mapping study OTUs to OTT taxa", "@id": "otu-mapping-hints", "@passedChecks": true, "@preserve": true, "@wasAssociatedWithAgentId": "opentree-curation-webapp", "message": [{"@code": "OTU_MAPPING_HINTS", "@humanMessageType": "NONE", "@severity": "INFO", "data": {"searchContext": {"$": "Birds"}, "substitutions": {"substitution": [{"@active": false, "@valid": true, "new": {"$": ""}, "old": {"$": ""}}]}, "useFuzzyMatching": false}, "refersTo": {"@top": {"$": "meta"}}}]}, {"@dateCreated": "2016-09-29T18:56:21.387Z", "@description": "Describes supporting data files for this study", "@id": "supporting-files-metadata", "@passedChecks": true, "@preserve": true, "@wasAssociatedWithAgentId": "opentree-curation-webapp", "message": [{"@code": "SUPPORTING_FILE_INFO", "@humanMessageType": "NONE", "@severity": "INFO", "data": {"@movedToPermanentArchive": false, "files": {"file": [{"@filename": "PASTED.nex", "@size": 1231, "@type": "nexus", "@url": "/curator/download/supporting_files.doc.a2ca31451cd20dbe.5041535445442e6e6578.nex", "description": {"$": "Source data for tree(s) 'tree1', 'tree2'"}, "sourceForTree": [{"$": "tree1"}, {"$": "tree2"}]}]}}, "refersTo": {"@top": {"$": "meta"}}}]}, {"@id": "peyotl-validator-event", "@description": "Open Tree NexSON validation", "@wasAssociatedWithAgentId": "peyotl-validator", "@passedChecks": true, "@preserve": false, "message": [{"@code": "UNRECOGNIZED_KEY", "data": ["^ot:comment"], "refersTo": {"@top": "nexml", "@idref": "study"}, "@severity": "WARNING"}, {"@code": "MISSING_OPTIONAL_KEY", "data": ["^ot:branchLengthTimeUnit"], "refersTo": {"@top": "trees", "@idref": "tree1", "@treesID": "trees1", "@treeID": "tree1"}, "@severity": "WARNING"}, {"@code": "UNRECOGNIZED_KEY", "data": ["^ot:nodeLabelMode", "^ot:nodeLabelTimeUnit"], "refersTo": {"@top": "trees", "@idref": "tree1", "@treesID": "trees1", "@treeID": "tree1"}, "@severity": "WARNING"}, {"@code": "UNRECOGNIZED_KEY", "data": ["rootedge"], "refersTo": {"@top": "trees", "@idref": "tree1", "@treesID": "trees1", "@treeID": "tree1"}, "@severity": "WARNING"}, {"@code": "MISSING_OPTIONAL_KEY", "data": ["^ot:branchLengthTimeUnit"], "refersTo": {"@top": "trees", "@idref": "tree2", "@treesID": "trees1", "@treeID": "tree2"}, "@severity": "WARNING"}, {"@code": "UNRECOGNIZED_KEY", "data": ["^ot:nodeLabelMode", "^ot:nodeLabelTimeUnit"], "refersTo": {"@top": "trees", "@idref": "tree2", "@treesID": "trees1", "@treeID": "tree2"}, "@severity": "WARNING"}, {"@code": "UNRECOGNIZED_KEY", "data": ["rootedge"], "refersTo": {"@top": "trees", "@idref": "tree2", "@treesID": "trees1", "@treeID": "tree2"}, "@severity": "WARNING"}]}]}, "^ot:candidateTreeForSynthesis": ["tree1"], "^ot:comment": "individual collapsed into species. \ntree from Davis 2014.", "^ot:curatorName": ["ningwang83"], "^ot:dataDeposit": {"@href": ""}, "^ot:focalClade": 565817, "^ot:focalCladeOTTTaxonName": "Sturnidae", "^ot:notIntendedForSynthesis": false, "^ot:otusElementOrder": ["otus1"], "^ot:studyId": "ot_848", "^ot:studyPublication": {"@href": "http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ympev.2008.01.020"}, "^ot:studyPublicationReference": "Irby J. Lovette, Brynn V. McCleery, Amanda L. Talaba, Dustin R. Rubenstein, 2008, 'A complete species-level molecular phylogeny for the \u201cEurasian\u201d starlings (Sturnidae: Sturnus, Acridotheres, and allies): Recent diversification in a highly social and dispersive avian group', Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, vol. 47, no. 1, pp. 251-260", "^ot:studyYear": 2008, "^ot:tag": [], "^ot:treesElementOrder": ["trees1"], "otusById": {"otus1": {"otuById": {"otu1": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus roseus", "^ot:ottId": 844091, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus roseus"}, "otu10": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus melanopterus", "^ot:ottId": 3598554, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus melanopterus"}, "otu11": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Acridotheres ginginianus", "^ot:ottId": 405017, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Acridotheres ginginianus"}, "otu12": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Acridotheres tristis", "^ot:ottId": 80701, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Acridotheres tristis"}, "otu13": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus cineraceus", "^ot:ottId": 499641, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus cineraceus"}, "otu14": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus sericeus", "^ot:ottId": 661325, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus sericeus"}, "otu15": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Leucopsar rothschildi", "^ot:ottId": 863246, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Leucopsar rothschildi"}, "otu16": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus senex", "^ot:ottId": 3598555, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus senex"}, "otu17": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus sinensis", "^ot:ottId": 2224, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus sinensis"}, "otu18": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus pagodarum", "^ot:ottId": 844099, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus pagodarum"}, "otu19": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus erythropygius", "^ot:ottId": 848364, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus erythropygius"}, "otu2": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Creatophora cinerea", "^ot:ottId": 79250, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Creatophora cinerea"}, "otu20": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus malabaricus", "^ot:ottId": 844094, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus malabaricus"}, "otu21": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus contra", "^ot:ottId": 844085, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus contra"}, "otu22": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus nigricollis", "^ot:ottId": 366471, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus nigricollis"}, "otu23": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus philippensis", "^ot:ottId": 844089, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus philippensis"}, "otu24": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus sturninus", "^ot:ottId": 848366, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus sturninus"}, "otu25": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus unicolor", "^ot:ottId": 366470, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus unicolor"}, "otu26": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus vulgaris", "^ot:ottId": 565813, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus vulgaris"}, "otu3": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Acridotheres albocinctus", "^ot:ottId": 544910, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Acridotheres albocinctus"}, "otu4": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Acridotheres cristatellus", "^ot:ottId": 405018, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Acridotheres cristatellus"}, "otu5": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Acridotheres grandis", "^ot:ottId": 405024, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Acridotheres grandis"}, "otu6": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Acridotheres fuscus", "^ot:ottId": 595025, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Acridotheres fuscus"}, "otu7": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Acridotheres cinereus", "^ot:ottId": 544911, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Acridotheres cinereus"}, "otu8": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Acridotheres javanicus", "^ot:ottId": 405023, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Acridotheres javanicus"}, "otu9": {"^ot:originalLabel": "Sturnus burmannicus", "^ot:ottId": 848363, "^ot:ottTaxonName": "Sturnus burmannicus"}}}}, "treesById": {"trees1": {"@otus": "otus1", "^ot:treeElementOrder": ["tree1", "tree2"], "treeById": {"tree1": {"@label": "lovette etal 2008 tree 1", "@xsi:type": "nex:IntTree", "^ot:branchLengthDescription": "", "^ot:branchLengthMode": "ot:undefined", "^ot:curatedType": "Bayesian inference ", "^ot:inGroupClade": "node1", "^ot:nodeLabelMode": "", "^ot:nodeLabelTimeUnit": "", "^ot:outGroupEdge": "", "^ot:rootNodeId": "node1", "^ot:specifiedRoot": "node1", "^ot:tag": [], "^ot:unrootedTree": false, "edgeBySourceId": {"node1": {"edge1": {"@source": "node1", "@target": "node2"}, "edge48": {"@source": "node1", "@target": "node49"}}, "node10": {"edge10": {"@source": "node10", "@target": "node11"}, "edge21": {"@source": "node10", "@target": "node22"}}, "node11": {"edge11": {"@source": "node11", "@target": "node12"}, "edge16": {"@source": "node11", "@target": "node17"}}, "node12": {"edge12": {"@source": "node12", "@target": "node13"}, "edge13": {"@source": "node12", "@target": "node14"}}, "node14": {"edge14": {"@source": "node14", "@target": "node15"}, "edge15": {"@source": "node14", "@target": "node16"}}, "node17": {"edge17": {"@source": "node17", "@target": "node18"}, "edge18": {"@source": "node17", "@target": "node19"}}, "node19": {"edge19": {"@source": "node19", "@target": "node20"}, "edge20": {"@source": "node19", "@target": "node21"}}, "node2": {"edge2": {"@source": "node2", "@target": "node3"}, "edge3": {"@source": "node2", "@target": "node4"}}, "node22": {"edge22": {"@source": "node22", "@target": "node23"}, "edge23": {"@source": "node22", "@target": "node24"}}, "node25": {"edge25": {"@source": "node25", "@target": "node26"}, "edge26": {"@source": "node25", "@target": "node27"}}, "node28": {"edge28": {"@source": "node28", "@target": "node29"}, "edge29": {"@source": "node28", "@target": "node30"}}, "node31": {"edge31": {"@source": "node31", "@target": "node32"}, "edge34": {"@source": "node31", "@target": "node35"}}, "node32": {"edge32": {"@source": "node32", "@target": "node33"}, "edge33": {"@source": "node32", "@target": "node34"}}, "node35": {"edge35": {"@source": "node35", "@target": "node36"}, "edge36": {"@source": "node35", "@target": "node37"}}, "node37": {"edge37": {"@source": "node37", "@target": "node38"}, "edge38": {"@source": "node37", "@target": "node39"}}, "node39": {"edge39": {"@source": "node39", "@target": "node40"}, "edge40": {"@source": "node39", "@target": "node41"}}, "node4": {"edge4": {"@source": "node4", "@target": "node5"}, "edge5": {"@source": "node4", "@target": "node6"}}, "node42": {"edge42": {"@source": "node42", "@target": "node43"}, "edge45": {"@source": "node42", "@target": "node46"}}, "node43": {"edge43": {"@source": "node43", "@target": "node44"}, "edge44": {"@source": "node43", "@target": "node45"}}, "node46": {"edge46": {"@source": "node46", "@target": "node47"}, "edge47": {"@source": "node46", "@target": "node48"}}, "node49": {"edge49": {"@source": "node49", "@target": "node50"}, "edge50": {"@source": "node49", "@target": "node51"}}, "node6": {"edge41": {"@source": "node6", "@target": "node42"}, "edge6": {"@source": "node6", "@target": "node7"}}, "node7": {"edge30": {"@source": "node7", "@target": "node31"}, "edge7": {"@source": "node7", "@target": "node8"}}, "node8": {"edge27": {"@source": "node8", "@target": "node28"}, "edge8": {"@source": "node8", "@target": "node9"}}, "node9": {"edge24": {"@source": "node9", "@target": "node25"}, "edge9": {"@source": "node9", "@target": "node10"}}}, "nodeById": {"node1": {"@root": true}, "node10": {}, "node11": {}, "node12": {}, "node13": {"@otu": "otu3"}, "node14": {}, "node15": {"@otu": "otu4"}, "node16": {"@otu": "otu5"}, "node17": {}, "node18": {"@otu": "otu6"}, "node19": {}, "node2": {}, "node20": {"@otu": "otu7"}, "node21": {"@otu": "otu8"}, "node22": {}, "node23": {"@otu": "otu9"}, "node24": {"@otu": "otu10"}, "node25": {}, "node26": {"@otu": "otu11"}, "node27": {"@otu": "otu12"}, "node28": {}, "node29": {"@otu": "otu13"}, "node3": {"@otu": "otu1"}, "node30": {"@otu": "otu14"}, "node31": {}, "node32": {}, "node33": {"@otu": "otu15"}, "node34": {"@otu": "otu16"}, "node35": {}, "node36": {"@otu": "otu17"}, "node37": {}, "node38": {"@otu": "otu18"}, "node39": {}, "node4": {}, "node40": {"@otu": "otu19"}, "node41": {"@otu": "otu20"}, "node42": {}, "node43": {}, "node44": {"@otu": "otu21"}, "node45": {"@otu": "otu22"}, "node46": {}, "node47": {"@otu": "otu23"}, "node48": {"@otu": "otu24"}, "node49": {}, "node5": {"@otu": "otu2"}, "node50": {"@otu": "otu25"}, "node51": {"@otu": "otu26"}, "node6": {}, "node7": {}, "node8": {}, "node9": {}}, "rootedge": [{"@id": "enode1", "@length": "0", "@target": "node1"}]}, "tree2": {"@label": "lovette etal 2008 tree 2", "@xsi:type": "nex:IntTree", "^ot:branchLengthDescription": "", "^ot:branchLengthMode": "ot:undefined", "^ot:curatedType": "Bayesian inference ", "^ot:inGroupClade": "node52", "^ot:nodeLabelMode": "", "^ot:nodeLabelTimeUnit": "", "^ot:outGroupEdge": "", "^ot:rootNodeId": "node52", "^ot:specifiedRoot": "node52", "^ot:tag": [], "^ot:unrootedTree": false, "edgeBySourceId": {"node100": {"edge100": {"@source": "node100", "@target": "node102"}, "edge99": {"@source": "node100", "@target": "node101"}}, "node52": {"edge51": {"@source": "node52", "@target": "node53"}, "edge98": {"@source": "node52", "@target": "node100"}}, "node53": {"edge52": {"@source": "node53", "@target": "node54"}, "edge53": {"@source": "node53", "@target": "node55"}}, "node55": {"edge54": {"@source": "node55", "@target": "node56"}, "edge55": {"@source": "node55", "@target": "node57"}}, "node57": {"edge56": {"@source": "node57", "@target": "node58"}, "edge91": {"@source": "node57", "@target": "node93"}}, "node58": {"edge57": {"@source": "node58", "@target": "node59"}, "edge80": {"@source": "node58", "@target": "node82"}}, "node59": {"edge58": {"@source": "node59", "@target": "node60"}, "edge59": {"@source": "node59", "@target": "node61"}}, "node61": {"edge60": {"@source": "node61", "@target": "node62"}, "edge61": {"@source": "node61", "@target": "node63"}}, "node63": {"edge62": {"@source": "node63", "@target": "node64"}, "edge77": {"@source": "node63", "@target": "node79"}}, "node64": {"edge63": {"@source": "node64", "@target": "node65"}, "edge74": {"@source": "node64", "@target": "node76"}}, "node65": {"edge64": {"@source": "node65", "@target": "node66"}, "edge69": {"@source": "node65", "@target": "node71"}}, "node66": {"edge65": {"@source": "node66", "@target": "node67"}, "edge66": {"@source": "node66", "@target": "node68"}}, "node68": {"edge67": {"@source": "node68", "@target": "node69"}, "edge68": {"@source": "node68", "@target": "node70"}}, "node71": {"edge70": {"@source": "node71", "@target": "node72"}, "edge71": {"@source": "node71", "@target": "node73"}}, "node73": {"edge72": {"@source": "node73", "@target": "node74"}, "edge73": {"@source": "node73", "@target": "node75"}}, "node76": {"edge75": {"@source": "node76", "@target": "node77"}, "edge76": {"@source": "node76", "@target": "node78"}}, "node79": {"edge78": {"@source": "node79", "@target": "node80"}, "edge79": {"@source": "node79", "@target": "node81"}}, "node82": {"edge81": {"@source": "node82", "@target": "node83"}, "edge82": {"@source": "node82", "@target": "node84"}}, "node84": {"edge83": {"@source": "node84", "@target": "node85"}, "edge84": {"@source": "node84", "@target": "node86"}}, "node86": {"edge85": {"@source": "node86", "@target": "node87"}, "edge86": {"@source": "node86", "@target": "node88"}}, "node88": {"edge87": {"@source": "node88", "@target": "node89"}, "edge88": {"@source": "node88", "@target": "node90"}}, "node90": {"edge89": {"@source": "node90", "@target": "node91"}, "edge90": {"@source": "node90", "@target": "node92"}}, "node93": {"edge92": {"@source": "node93", "@target": "node94"}, "edge95": {"@source": "node93", "@target": "node97"}}, "node94": {"edge93": {"@source": "node94", "@target": "node95"}, "edge94": {"@source": "node94", "@target": "node96"}}, "node97": {"edge96": {"@source": "node97", "@target": "node98"}, "edge97": {"@source": "node97", "@target": "node99"}}}, "nodeById": {"node100": {}, "node101": {"@otu": "otu25"}, "node102": {"@otu": "otu26"}, "node52": {"@root": true}, "node53": {}, "node54": {"@otu": "otu1"}, "node55": {}, "node56": {"@otu": "otu2"}, "node57": {}, "node58": {}, "node59": {}, "node60": {"@otu": "otu13"}, "node61": {}, "node62": {"@otu": "otu14"}, "node63": {}, "node64": {}, "node65": {}, "node66": {}, "node67": {"@otu": "otu3"}, "node68": {}, "node69": {"@otu": "otu4"}, "node70": {"@otu": "otu5"}, "node71": {}, "node72": {"@otu": "otu7"}, "node73": {}, "node74": {"@otu": "otu6"}, "node75": {"@otu": "otu8"}, "node76": {}, "node77": {"@otu": "otu9"}, "node78": {"@otu": "otu10"}, "node79": {}, "node80": {"@otu": "otu11"}, "node81": {"@otu": "otu12"}, "node82": {}, "node83": {"@otu": "otu16"}, "node84": {}, "node85": {"@otu": "otu15"}, "node86": {}, "node87": {"@otu": "otu17"}, "node88": {}, "node89": {"@otu": "otu18"}, "node90": {}, "node91": {"@otu": "otu19"}, "node92": {"@otu": "otu20"}, "node93": {}, "node94": {}, "node95": {"@otu": "otu21"}, "node96": {"@otu": "otu22"}, "node97": {}, "node98": {"@otu": "otu23"}, "node99": {"@otu": "otu24"}}, "rootedge": [{"@id": "enode52", "@length": "0", "@target": "node52"}]}}}}}}, "branch2sha": {"master": "3f7bd72a0486fba3f756bbb61fabda2acf6c259f"}, "commentHTML": "<p>individual collapsed into species. \ntree from Davis 2014.</p>", "duplicateStudyIDs": [], "shardName": "phylesystem-1", "versionHistory": [{"id": "186aef2e11907b8b5bfa753a935b9e6c20411030", "author_name": "ningwang83", "author_email": "ANONYMOUS", "date": "Thu, 29 Sep 2016 19:05:33 +0000", "date_ISO_8601": "2016-09-29 19:05:33 +0000", "relative_date": "10 years ago", "message_subject": "make comments", "message_body": "(Update document 'ot_848' via OpenTree API)"}, {"id": "38e0eedc95a830a48ebf1049dedfca1a4a81e3d9", "author_name": "ningwang83", "author_email": "ANONYMOUS", "date": "Thu, 29 Sep 2016 19:05:05 +0000", "date_ISO_8601": "2016-09-29 19:05:05 +0000", "relative_date": "10 years ago", "message_subject": "set up trees", "message_body": "(Update document 'ot_848' via OpenTree API)"}, {"id": "a98f24f614abc5a4fdc2d456ea3df2bff6740d27", "author_name": "ningwang83", "author_email": "ANONYMOUS", "date": "Thu, 29 Sep 2016 18:59:50 +0000", "date_ISO_8601": "2016-09-29 18:59:50 +0000", "relative_date": "10 years ago", "message_subject": "map OTUs", "message_body": "(Update document 'ot_848' via OpenTree API)"}, {"id": "b277ee1b8dc9d20f1d556ca738861ec2110d277d", "author_name": "ningwang83", "author_email": "ANONYMOUS", "date": "Thu, 29 Sep 2016 18:57:44 +0000", "date_ISO_8601": "2016-09-29 18:57:44 +0000", "relative_date": "10 years ago", "message_subject": "init", "message_body": "(Update document 'ot_848' via OpenTree API)"}, {"id": "dbc266a03a07d85955eca2213fd442061fd3a242", "author_name": "ningwang83", "author_email": "ANONYMOUS", "date": "Thu, 29 Sep 2016 18:56:20 +0000", "date_ISO_8601": "2016-09-29 18:56:20 +0000", "relative_date": "10 years ago", "message_subject": "Update document 'ot_848' via OpenTree API"}]}